The Unfolding Tragedy that is the Temple Mount

March 15, 2015 by Gil Solomon
Read on for article

The Temple Mount is a place where the “Dome of the Rock” mosque now stands but was once the place where the First and Second Jewish Temples stood…writes Gil Solomon.

Gil Solomon

Gil Solomon

The facts are that the Muslim Waqf were allowed to retain control of the Temple Mount, this holiest of Jewish sites only because of then Chief of Staff Moshe Dayan’s desire to be magnanimous in victory after the 1967 war. Contrary to popular misconceptions, Rabbis at the time wanted Israeli control over this holy site while researching which part, according to Halacha, of this hallowed ground Jews were not allowed to go, a search the Waqf made difficult by sealing off underground areas.

In fact, this decision by Dayan changed the course of history for the Jewish people in a profound and negative way. They could have had it all but squandered this chance that presented itself on a platter. With an issue so profound, any general, as the victor and steeped in our history and heritage could have forced each and every Waqf official to identify every single area that had been sealed. Apparently the Jewish world had no such general at the time. Jews caved in then, as they do now.

Putting aside Dayan’s spectacular, heroic and brilliant military career, this thoroughly secular individual with no real concept or depth of understanding of Jewish destiny or heritage or Torah, in his stupidity is the one that allowed the Waqf to retain control of the Temple Mount after the 1967 war, a control which continues till this day. It is enough to make one weep. It doesn’t say much about the people around him at the time in the cabinet, who allowed this decision to prevail.

Below are some dates to put the Temple history in perspective.

The first Temple was built by King Solomon in 960 BCE

It was destroyed by Nebuchadnezzer in 586 BCE

The second Temple was built around 520 BCE

This one was destroyed by Titus in 70 AD

Herod reigned from 37 BCE to 4 BCE. He is the one that enlarged and beautified the grounds of the second temple by the construction of what is now known as the “Wailing Wall” the courtyard perimeter wall surrounding the Temple Mount compound, remains of what you see in existence today in postcards.

This “wall” was apparently enough for those Israelis in power in ‘67, not the treasure that was the Temple Mount itself and what lay beneath. After all these decades, Jews who now go to the Temple Mount are not allowed by the Muslim Waqf in groups of ten or more or to even move their lips (in case they are praying). This decision all those years ago has allowed Muslims to go on excavating under the Temple Mount, destroying any remaining Jewish artifacts in order to rid the place of any trace of the first and second Temple periods and in the process, continue with the construction of an underground mosque there for future proof of claim to the land. All this happening while that insane democracy called Israel, looks the other way for fear of offending the UN, the world or whoever. A nation which in 1967 had all the cards but has since then squandered the lot with one concession after the other to a people who never existed in all of history. Had this site been retained after the 1967 victory, visiting foreign dignitaries would have been escorted to the Temple Mount, the reclaimed birthright of the Jewish people, instead of Yad Vashem, a memorial to the slaughter of 6 million of our people in the holocaust. In summary, this fateful decision by Moshe Dayan was, in my opinion, one of the defining mistakes in recent Jewish history.

Now we all watch in horror as so called “Palestinians” have picnics and play soccer on these hallowed grounds. As to the “Palestinians” and their incessant claims, the facts are that in biblical times, all of what is now Israel and the “west bank” (Judea and Samaria) was Jewish. When the Romans conquered the territory they named the entire area “Philistina” in order to rub salt into the wounds of the defeated Jews by calling the place in honour of their ancient and mortal enemies the Philistines. By doing so, the Romans acknowledged that the owners of the territory were Jews. Down the centuries the name Philistina was anglicised to Palestine.

At the beginning of the 20th Century, if one were referred to as a Palestinian, it was automatically implied that he or she was Jewish. Decades later Arabs cleverly commandeered the term “Palestinian” and fools the world over, including Jewish fools, have bought the propaganda that “Palestinians” have never forgiven the division of their “country” by the UN. If there was such a country, who were its rulers, what was is currency, the questions are endless but no one poses these types of questions to the Palestinian Authority.

The facts are that there was no country called Palestine.

Simply put, Palestine was a land mass administered finally by the British until the 1947 Partition Plan when only a part was allocated back to its century’s old rightful owners, the Jewish people.

Successive Israeli governments have never once opened their mouth in a convincing way to debunk the entire “Palestinian” narrative and in the process appear to have discarded the Jewish heritage of the Temple Mount.

So much for the profound: “If I forget thee O Jerusalem.”

Does no one see the consequences of this tragic situation?

It is time for Israel to act like a sovereign power in control of its own destiny and take unilateral action on many fronts, including the reclaiming of the Temple Mount before it is lost forever.

In short, it is time for the gloves to finally come off.


Author Gil Solomon is a retired finance manager who takes an intense interest in current affairs impacting on the Jewish community.


3 Responses to “The Unfolding Tragedy that is the Temple Mount”
  1. Eleonora Mostert says:

    Shalom Gil, Not to worry they didn’t stop every Jew from praying on the Temple Mount. I stood right at the entrance of the Dome of the Rock and prayed that it would be demolished and the Temple rebuilt. I even asked the angry man if I could go in to take a photo of The Rock. If I get the chance to go back, I’ll take it a step further and learn to pray in Aramaic to the God of Abraham Isaac and Jacob. They sure don’t scare me. Paul Winter you left some descriptions of these people out .Marauding Murderers to name 2

  2. Erica Edelman says:

    On reading this, and I must admit I am a little short on historical fact around the era 70AD, I can see some similarities between Dayan and Netanyahu. Both were/are intent on winning the battles, but NOT losing the war.
    Don’t worry, Gil and Paul, Netanyahu knows all about Palestine – the name, where it came from and who and which battles were fought leading up to today. It is only a matter of a short time that Israel will be able to take back territory which is indeed truly Jewish territory. You have, in the past, accused me, Gil, of “touchy, feely” political views – well, sit back because its just a matter of a few short years and Netanyahu and his people will be sitting pretty on land rightfully theirs..Israel’s Arab neighbours are making too many mistakes which will ultimately be their ruin.

  3. Paul Winter says:

    Absolutely Gil! Jewish leaders should never have allowed a maliciously concocted “people” to steal our history and religion and then trample on our rights.

    I am not religious, but if my religious brothers and sisters want to pray on our holiest site I am 100% with them.

    I object to any bloodthirsty pack of antisemites claiming a right for themselves that they deny to others. I object to the governing elite of the nation state of the Jewish people allowing its majority to become dhimmis. And I most strongly object to the international community which demands that Jews share their land with a pretend people, saying not a word when those same aggressive, callous, lying pack of pretenders refuses to share a site holy to Jews and significant to mohammedans only on an interpretation of a dream.

Speak Your Mind

Comments received without a full name will not be considered
Email addresses are NEVER published! All comments are moderated. J-Wire will publish considered comments by people who provide a real name and email address. Comments that are abusive, rude, defamatory or which contain offensive language will not be published

Got something to say about this?

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.