“State of Palestine” set to confront Trump at United Nations

January 23, 2019 by David Singer
Read on for article

The bizarre Handover ceremony of Egypt’s Chairmanship of the Group of 77 to the “State of Palestine” for 2019 will enable this non-existent and non-member State of the United Nations to play a leading role in the 74 years old farce –“The Question of Palestine and the United Nations” (PUN).

“The State of Palestine”does not meet the criteria for statehood required under the 1933 Montevideo Convention.

The Group of 77 (“the Bloc”) contains 133 of the 193 member states of the United Nations– ensuring the automatic passage of all United Nations General Assembly (UNGA) resolutions they propose.

UNGA Resolution A/RES/73/5– adopted on 16 October 2018 – put this illusory “State of Palestine” centre stage for PUN’s 2019 New York season – recognising it as the Bloc’s public face in all matters brought before UNGA and at meetings of representatives of other major groups.

146 countries voted for this Resolution whilst only three – Israel, the U.S. and Australia – voted against, 15 countries abstained and the remaining 29 states did not vote.

US Deputy UN Ambassador Jonathan Cohen called out the hypocrisy of the vote:

 “We cannot support efforts by the Palestinians to enhance their status outside of direct negotiations. The United States does not recognize that there is a Palestinian state. … Only U.N. member states should be entitled to speak and act on behalf of major groups of states at the United Nations.”

Australia’s UN Ambassador Gillian Bird asserted:

“Australia’s decision to vote no on this resolution reflects our long-standing position that Palestinian attempts to seek recognition as a state in international fora are deeply unhelpful to efforts towards a two-state solution.”

The Handover Ceremony took place in the presence of UNGA President Ms Maria Fernanda Espinosa Garcés, UN Secretary-General Mr António Gutteres, Mahmoud Abbas – the self-styled “President of the State of Palestine”(formerly called “the Palestinian Authority” before Abbas unilaterally changed its name in 2013) and Bloc members.

Mr Gutteres’ 12 minutes speech contained this politically-charged statement:

“Palestine and its citizens have first-hand experience of some of the most challenging and dramatic global issues at force”

Regrettably, the Secretary-General failed to elaborate on where he believed “Palestine” is located, who he considers are its citizens, its capital, the area it controls and its current government.

The Handover Ceremony included a 1-hour concert featuring live performances of Astor Piazolla’s “Oblivion”, a Brahms sonata for violin and piano, five works by three Egyptian composers extending over 26 minutes and just 4 minutes of “Palestinian folk songs” whose provenance was not mentioned in the program notes.

One Egyptian composition – “Lessa Faker” – aptly describes the path UNGA needs to take to end this blatant “State of Palestine” fakery that flagrantly violates international law.

“Foreign Minister” of the “State of Palestine” Riyad Malki has impertinently predicted:

 “… we are confident that [the Bloc] will support the Palestinians when it [sic] time comes for negotiations and the US will find out that it cannot ignore Palestine.”

Malki’s claim is risible.

America has denied the existence of any State of Palestine for the last seven decades. President Trump has closed the PLO diplomatic offices in Washington and ceased America’s annual payments of $360 million to UNRWA.  The PLO refuses to entertain any Trump peace proposals designed to end the Arab-Jewish conflict.

President Trump’s response could well see him consigning the“State of Palestine” to diplomatic oblivion to the accompanying strains of Piazolla’s Oblivion – with the United Nations left lamenting at the wake that it holds for the phantom State.

This is truly Theatre of the AbsurdMultilateralism gone mad.

Author’s note: The cartoon — commissioned exclusively for this article — is by Yaakov Kirschen aka “Dry Bones”- one of Israel’s foremost political and social commentators — whose cartoons have graced the columns of Israeli and international media publications for decades. His cartoons can be viewed at Drybonesblog


6 Responses to ““State of Palestine” set to confront Trump at United Nations”
  1. David Singer says:


    The 1933 convention is still binding international law in 2019.
    The League of Nations Mandate for Palestine still has relevance in 2019 because of the provisions of article 80 of the United Nations Charter.

  2. Brian Rom says:

    The problem with your article is that its dishonest. Strictly speaking Palestine is not yet a state under the accepted legal definition. No one disputes that. But you dont support Palestinian statehood anyway. You dont believe they have rights of self determination or that they should ever have a state in the west bank. You support the bizarre idea of re-assigning Palestinians as Jordanian citizens, which is ethnic cleansing by other means.

    I also find the mocking tone of this and many of your articles quite childish.

    • David Singer says:


      1. You assert: “Strictly speaking Palestine is not yet a state under the accepted legal definition. No one disputes that.”

      On what basis then can you explain Palestine’s admission to UNESCO in 2011 when only states are entitled to be admitted as members under UNESCO’s Constitution?

      2. You further assert that “re-assigning Palestinians as Jordanian citizens” is “ethnic cleansing by other means”

      The Arab residents of Judea and Samaria (West Bank) were Jordanian citizens between 1950 and 1988 and no one to my knowledge called that “ethnic cleansing” during that 38 year period.

      3. What I believe are these indisputable facts and the solution to a conflict that has raged unresolved for 100 years.

      (a) 95% of former Palestine has already been divided between Arabs and Jews into two states known as Jordan and Israel.
      (b) the remaining 5% should be allocated between Jordan and Israel in direct negotiations.

      You appear to believe that a second Arab State should be created in either all or part of Judea and Samaria (West Bank). That solution has failed to eventuate after negotiations spanning the last 25 years. I believe any such solution was destined to fail from its attempted outset in 1993 beginning with the Oslo Accords – because it ignored binding international law as articulated in the Mandate for Palestine.

      4. Generalised unsubstantiated claims and ad hominem attacks that you make in your opening and closing sentences – designed to shoot the messenger and ignore the message – are counterproductive and irrelevant. Concentrate on the article – not the author.

  3. Herbert Sternberg says:

    Another “educated” man who does not know the spelling of PIAZZOLLA

    • David Singer says:


      Sorry for the typos – though I didn’t appreciate the tenor of your comment.
      As someone apparently far more “educated” – have you nothing further to comment on about the subject matter of the article?

  4. Adrian Jackson says:

    A 1933 convention from a now defunct League of Nation.

Speak Your Mind

Comments received without a full name will not be considered
Email addresses are NEVER published! All comments are moderated. J-Wire will publish considered comments by people who provide a real name and email address. Comments that are abusive, rude, defamatory or which contain offensive language will not be published

Got something to say about this?

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.