Jeremy Corbyn didn’t win, so British Jews shouldn’t give up on Labour

June 21, 2017 by Ben Cohen -
Read on for article

For me, the main takeaway from the British election June 8 was that Jeremy Corbyn, the far-left leader of the opposition Labour party, didn’t win it…writes Ben Cohen/

Most of the ridicule in the wake of the election has been aimed at Conservative party Prime Minister Theresa May, for her political error worthy of an Elizabethan farce—calling an election with the aim of increasing her majority, only to end up needing the votes of a right-wing Unionist party in Northern Ireland in order to form a government.

The scorn heaped on May by most of the British media has been matched with fulsome praise tossed in Corbyn’s direction. Since Labour, under his leadership, had been tipped for electoral annihilation, the fact that he received a respectable portion of the vote was heralded as if he’d actually won the thing.

For Labour, the last decade has mirrored its experience in the 1980s. Back then—at a time when there was no Twitter universe for left-wing activists to counter the invective directed at the party from right-wing tabloid newspapers—Labour, with its myriad far-left factions, became an electoral wreck.

Jeremy Corbyn. Credit: Paul New via Wikimedia Commons.

Towards the end of the Margaret Thatcher era, a Labour leader named Neil Kinnock brought the party guardedly back into the mainstream. But Labour didn’t win an election for nearly 20 years until Tony Blair won handsomely in 1997—and that fact, more than any other, continues to nag at Corbyn and his acolytes, who dream of a reinvented party firmly on the socialist left.

Corbyn came out of the 2017 election more than 60 seats short of a working parliamentary majority. To my mind, for him to win an election remains a tall order. If there’s another one soon, he’ll have to mobilize the youth vote all over again—much easier said than done—and he’ll need to pray for another benevolent news cycle in which all the focus is on the errors and slips of his opponent.

If there’s another election much later, he will still need to deal with the ironclad doubts a majority of British voters retain about his suitability to lead their country.

One of the most troubling spectacles of Corbyn’s tenure has, of course, been the numerous antisemitism scandals plaguing the party, often involving key Labour figures—like former London Mayor Ken Livingstone, who remains discreetly suspended, rather than expelled, for telling open lies about Adolf Hitler’s alleged “support” for Zionism. There is, therefore, a whiff of schadenfreude in the air when you realize that had Corbyn taken the issue of antisemitism seriously, had he not embraced “friends” like Hamas and Hezbollah, he might have been in a position to make Theresa May’s attempts to form a governing coalition nearly impossible.

In four districts in northern London, all with significant Jewish populations, the overall swing to Labour in the city wasn’t enough to overcome to overcome the Conservative candidates. At least two of the defeated Labour candidates said afterwards that the party’s electoral fortunes in these London constituencies had been damaged by the antisemitism scandals. But had Labour won these four parliamentary seats—and it came agonizingly close to doing so—May would have been forced to turn to hostile opposition parties to form a government. Had that happened, she would likely have failed.

Yet Labour remains a force in British politics, and I modestly hope British Jews won’t give up on the party. One lesson the party can take from its 2017 experience at the polls is that winning elections is possible—if certain aspects are appropriately tweaked. Whether those Labour figures who still have some influence within the party, and some distance from Corbyn, can persuade the members that a leadership change should be one of those aspects doesn’t strike me as hugely viable.

Ben Cohen

But British Jews can play a role in ensuring the party isn’t entirely hijacked by the far left, which regards BDS as an article of faith and dismisses any charge of antisemitism as a Mossad-directed smear campaign. Jews certainly have Labour allies—both established ones, like John Mann, a parliamentarian who has diligently combated antisemitism for more than a decade, and new ones, like London Mayor Sadiq Khan.

This week, Khan told a Jewish gathering in London what they had been waiting to hear from a Labour politician for many months. “The Labour must rebuild trust with you, the Jewish community—it can’t be acceptable that there is any community that feels the Labour party is not on their side,” he said.

There was another remark from Khan that caught my eye: “There is no hierarchy in racism. Racism is racism.” That is an exquisitely bold statement for someone to make in the age of intersectionality—which argues there is, in fact, a hierarchy in racism, and that Jews are very low down on it—and it is also a message Labour needs to absorb.

Khan’s challenge to his party on the antisemitism issue is particularly significant during a week when even liberals in America are cooing on their admiration for Corbyn—and this should be borne in mind by those tempted to side with President Donald Trump in his bizarre Twitter campaign against the London mayor. Friends can be found where you least expect them, after all.

Ben Cohen writes a weekly column for on Jewish affairs and Middle Eastern politics. His writings have been published in Commentary, the New York Post, Haaretz, The Wall Street Journal and many other publications.


One Response to “Jeremy Corbyn didn’t win, so British Jews shouldn’t give up on Labour”
  1. David Adler says:

    “…so British Jews shouldn’t give up on Labour”

    To propose a British response “I think that’s a right load of old codswallop”.

    For British Jews, things came frighteningly close to a point of a Labour PM who has regarded Hezbollah and Hamas as friends.

    There is a profound lesson for Australian Jews concerning the Labor Party here which is also approaching a tipping point. Later this month alternate Labor leader Albanese together with Tony Burke will host Bob Carr at an ALP policy forum to discuss a Palestinian state. Within the ALP let’s not fail to see the signs – a policy tipping point is near.

Speak Your Mind

Comments received without a full name will not be considered
Email addresses are NEVER published! All comments are moderated. J-Wire will publish considered comments by people who provide a real name and email address. Comments that are abusive, rude, defamatory or which contain offensive language will not be published

Got something to say about this?

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.