The urgent need for proper Jewish leadership

July 24, 2022 by Melanie Phillips -
Read on for article

Diaspora Jews worry about how to deal with the current tsunami of anti-Semitism that is washing through the world.

Melanie Phillips

They also worry about how to deal with the anti-Zionism and demonisation of Israel that are now the default position for “progressives” in the West.

Most painful of all, they observe with horror that Jews themselves are increasingly involved in the onslaught against Israel.

However, there’s a problem that’s even more fundamental to the well-being of the Jewish people. It’s that Diaspora Jews are increasingly turning away from and even against Judaism itself.

Throughout the Diaspora, Jewish communities are dwindling in number as assimilation takes its toll. Nowhere is this more acute in America, where it takes a particularly baleful form.

Many American Jews haven’t just become detached from Judaism. They have embraced the sectarian ideologies of “social justice” that are in fact inimical to Judaism but which they nevertheless tell themselves are Jewish values.

They call this tikkun olam, claiming they accord with the Jewish concept of repairing the world. In fact, they profoundly distort tikkun olam, which is premised on the belief in God that these liberal Jews generally dismiss as irrelevant or an impediment to social progress.

Core Jewish principles involve putting others’ interests before your own, respecting every human being and observing moral codes based on right and wrong. By contrast, the social-justice agenda places the individual at the centre of existence so that objective truths are replaced by subjective opinions, feelings trump moral codes, and duties are replaced by rights.

Britain’s Jewish community, which is dwindling more gently, is different. Although many British Jews are socially liberal, they have never claimed the social-justice agenda as a Jewish moral code. In general elections, moreover, the majority actually vote Conservative. This is even though most British Jews who arrived from Eastern Europe in the early 20th century brought with them, just like their American cousins, a deep attachment to the Labor movement and even Communist politics.

And just as American Jews came to identify the Republican Party with anti-Semitism, British Jews formerly regarded the Conservative party as prejudiced against Jews while Labour was seen for decades as their natural home.

So why the difference over Jewish values? Maybe the reason is that, despite the anti-Semitism that always bubbles below the surface in any Western society, America was a salad of cultures and ethnicities.

Unlike Britain, whose indigenous and ancient culture meant that—however assimilated Jews became—they always felt themselves at some level to be outsiders, American Jews believed they were as American as anyone else.

Since the essence of Jewish identity is to be distinct from everyone else, this laid the groundwork for an existential conflict between Jewishness and Americanness. For the majority, this would only be resolved by hollowing out their Jewishness into a cosmetic but meaningless shell.

I discussed this neuralgic issue on this week’s JNS podcast with Rabbi Cary Kozberg, a Reform rabbi who has broken with the Reform movement over what he considers to be its embrace of the anti-Jewish values of the social-justice agenda.

Although Conservative Judaism now marches to a similar tune, Kozberg believes that the onslaught on Jewish principles has been driven by Reform. What worries him so much is that we’ve seen all this before.

Around the time of the destruction of the Second Temple, Greek culture—or Hellenism—attracted many Jews tempted by the opportunity to embrace hedonism and pagan decadence. Worse still, this caused divisions between Jews that fatally weakened the community and made it vulnerable to its external enemies who wanted the Jewish people gone.

Kozberg’s deepest fear is that American Jews are repeating this baleful history. The tragedy is that they don’t realize it because they don’t actually know the history of their own people.

This ignorance isn’t confined to progressive Jews. Among the young—even those who come from Orthodox backgrounds, and have been through Jewish day schools and Jewish camps and so on—are often astonishingly ignorant of what is necessary to keep the generational Jewish show on the road.

They tend to be taught from a narrow template of rabbinical texts and halachic ordinances. Whether Orthodox or progressive, the young aren’t generally taught much Jewish history or how Jewish moral principles can enrich their own personal lives and help surmount the pressures of modern existence.

They aren’t taught that Jewish precepts are absolutely foundational to Western values such as freedom, compassion and even rationality.

They aren’t taught why the Jewish emphasis on making distinctions between things is so vital to a moral sense, and how this runs directly counter to prevailing secular orthodoxies of equity and nondiscrimination.

They aren’t taught about the importance and centrality of Jewish uniqueness, and that what drives certain Jews to turn against the Jewish people is their anxiety to erase that uniqueness from their identity and sign up instead to the prevailing consensus.

They aren’t taught that Judaism is joyous and life-enhancing so that it can make their own lives more satisfying and optimistic.

In short, young Diaspora Jews are taught precious little about what has kept Jews together as a people despite overwhelming pressures, and why this is so valuable and important for these young Jews themselves.

Two things need to change if the Jewish people are properly to defend themselves: Jews need to be taught better about their own people, culture and history; and there needs to be a more effective strategy to fight their enemies by getting off the defensive back foot, and onto a pro-active and aggressive front foot.

Precious little of this is done at present because the Diaspora leadership is woefully inadequate: timid, servile and anxious to fit in.

In Britain, Jewish leaders publicly fought the far-left Labour Party leader Jeremy Corbyn because they felt safe in the knowledge that most people in the country reviled him as a dangerous extremist. But they refuse to fight Muslim anti-Semitism for fear of being called “Islamophobic.” Nor will they declare the demonstrable legitimacy of Israeli residency in the disputed territories of Judea and Samaria—not least because so many of these leaders are ignorant of this themselves.

In America, Jews are increasingly living in a state of siege. Jews have been murdered in Pittsburgh, San Diego and Jersey City. Visibly Jewish pedestrians are beaten regularly in the streets of American cities and towns. Jewish students are bullied and harassed on campus. The Democratic Party exhibits either indifference to all this or even tolerates the virulent anti-Jewish prejudice in “The Squad” of congresswomen.

American Jewish leaders either lend support to such people and their ideologies or else behave like rabbits frozen in the headlights. Now a grassroots movement has just launched to hold their feet to the fire.

The Jewish Leadership Project has a 10-point “action list” to mobilise a more effective Jewish defence. It demands that major Jewish organisations “cease subordinating the safety and welfare of the Jewish-American community to partisan ideology.”

The project’s co-founder, Avi Goldwasser, said: “Many once-venerable Jewish organisations have primarily become front groups for progressive political interests. The significant danger the Jewish community faces today is an indictment of these institutions and their leadership.”

All over the West, people have been left demoralised and disillusioned by an entire political establishment that appears determined to send Western civilisation off the edge of the cliff.

They’ve been rising up against this using whatever opportunities come their way. In Britain, it was Brexit; in America, it was the election of former president Donald Trump.

It’s time the Jewish people told their own Diaspora leaders “enough is enough,” and demand they start properly to defend the Jewish people rather than their own exalted positions.

Melanie Phillips, a British journalist, broadcaster and author, writes a weekly column for JNS. Currently a columnist for “The Times of London,” her personal and political memoir, “Guardian Angel,” has been published by Bombardier, which also published her first novel, “The Legacy.” Go to to access her work.


3 Responses to “The urgent need for proper Jewish leadership”
  1. Michael Burd says:

    Melanie Phillips right on the mark as usual. Our woke main stream organisations need to read this very insightful piece very much targeted at them in Sydney and Melbourne.
    Is it any wonder there was a need for a Jewish politically conservative non woke organization in Australia and the reason not withstanding the huge pushback by both our woke organizations and Jewish media AJA have been hugely successful .
    Is it any wonder when Skynews presenters want a Jewish representative to discuss Israel or Jewish related issues without all the woke and spin they have AJA,s DrDavid Adler on speed dial .

  2. Rabbi Chaim Ingram OAM says:

    Another right-on-the button-article from Melanie Phillips. In America, the land of the free, immigrants at the turn of the 20th century either jettisoned Shabbat (sadly sometimes because they weren’t able to secure employment without working on Saturdays) or saw it as a burden to be borne, an attitude which was conveyed to the children. Consequently, Orthodoxy didn’t stand much of a chance. The long-term result is what we have today. Thankfully US Jewry isn’t typical of most Diaspora Jewries though of course they have weight because of their sheer numbers. This too will start to change as as non-Orthodox communities assimilate and charedi communities burgeon..

  3. Liat Kirby says:

    The American Jews have always been significantly different to Diaspora Jews elsewhere (not only to British Jews), and it’s not only their leaders who cause this difference. It is, I think, more due to their not wanting to be singled out as ‘other’ (which you have already referred to in discussion) and, for some reason, not being comfortable with a tension they perceive between being American and being Jewish. Then you add the current narrowed liberalist thinking pervading the West, and it’s a nasty recipe.

    This is not something that bothers Australian Jews, who feel perfectly adequate as Australians and as Jews and allegiance to both takes its place naturally. Jews in Australia do not feel like outsiders as you mention they do in Britain due to Britain’s ‘indigenous and ancient culture’ – read entrenched class attitudes that still have their day, causing polarisation – as, despite the racism generally that will be found anywhere also existing, Australia is a more egalitarian society. Political correctness and stereotyped liberal attitudes preventing a more eclectic tolerance are though taking their toll, It is our First Nation’s people, the Aboriginals, who have suffered the most here and it’s that that needs redress.

    Jewish education is extremely important for better understanding and pride, however, we need to educate not just ourselves (which is what we tend to do), but extend that education to non-Jews, too. If that could be achieved, stereotypes and assumptions would perhaps start falling away, not for rabid antisemites though.

Speak Your Mind

Comments received without a full name will not be considered
Email addresses are NEVER published! All comments are moderated. J-Wire will publish considered comments by people who provide a real name and email address. Comments that are abusive, rude, defamatory or which contain offensive language will not be published

Got something to say about this?

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.