Shabbat Noach: The Curse of Canaan

October 8, 2021 by Jeremy Rosen
Read on for article
After the great flood, Noah emerged from the arc with his family. He offered a thanksgiving sacrifice to God. And then the first thing he did was to plant a vineyard and make wine.

I suppose if you had been locked up for a whole year in an arc with all those animals, you might well turn to alcohol for comfort! Sadly, Noah got drunk, and he was rolling around naked in his tent. His youngest son Ham came in and saw him there and went and told his brothers, Shem and Yafet. They took a blanket between them and walked back over the naked Noah so as not to see their father and covered him. When Noah woke up, he realized what his younger son had done to him.

The Torah doesn’t tell us what Ham had done. The authors of the Midrash offered a range of different options, from sexual interference, to simply a lack of respect. When Noah regained his balance and realized what had happened, strangely he did not curse Ham, but  Canaan the son of Ham. He said that he would always be a servant of servants. What was his intention with the curse?

The Torah often uses curses to express disapproval and blessings to express approval. But not to determine fate, or the future irrevocably. After all, repentance is encouraged from the very start for everyone. Yet many churches have used this text to justify slavery. South Africans well know that the Dutch Reformed Church for many years maintained it as an article of faith that the blacks were cursed by the Bible and this empowered them to impose Apartheid.

Avraham Ibn Ezra, the great Spanish commentator on the Bible who lived a thousand years ago, says on this text, that only fools take it to mean an ongoing curse. He points out that there were Canaanite kings who lived for many generations long after the curse. Which does not make sense if the curse meant that they should be powerless. There were Canaanite kings ruling for many years until the Assyrians finally exterminated them. Besides Canaan is not the same as Africa and does not imply black or any other colour necessarily. So those people who say that the blacks are cursed as a result of this biblical text don’t know what the hell they’re talking about. Yet this myth was perpetuated.

So, what did Canaan’s curse mean? There is a theme that runs through Genesis that implies that Canaan was morally and sexually corrupt. Which explains why it was that God allowed them to be displaced by the Israelites. And at the same time told the Israelites that if they did not do better, they too would be dispossessed. This is a metaphorical way of saying that some cultures are simply worse and more corrupt than others. In making the choices as to how we should live, we should avoid the Canaanite option over all others.

A blessing in the Bible in addition to praise implies that good things will come out of a good person. A blessing is an encouragement to do good. A curse implies bad things. But it is never and can’t be a general statement about individual humans being condemned forever. Even with a curse, we see that human beings have the opportunity to change. I consider this to be a very important message for us now in the 21st century that the distinction has to be made between people who behave ethically and those who don’t behave ethically. Just like earlier corrupt tribes, regardless of what background they come from, we should avoid the bad and cling to the good.

Genesis 6.9-12

Speak Your Mind

Comments received without a full name will not be considered
Email addresses are NEVER published! All comments are moderated. J-Wire will publish considered comments by people who provide a real name and email address. Comments that are abusive, rude, defamatory or which contain offensive language will not be published

Got something to say about this?

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.