Palestine: Jew Haters – Like Koran Burners – Cannot be Condoned

September 11, 2010 by David Singer
Read on for article

It did not take very long for the Palestinian Authority to make its unequivocal rejection of a Jewish State crystal clear following the pomp and circumstance of resumed negotiations between it and Israel in Washington last week.

Dr Nabeel Shaath – a member of the Palestinian Negotiating Team, the Fatah Central Committee and the Palestinian Legislative Council – told a press conference in Ramallah on 7 September:

“The Palestinian National Authority will never recognise that Israel is the national state for Jewish people, as such recognition will directly threaten the Muslim and Christian Palestinians in Israel, and will prevent the Palestinian refugees who left their homes and towns decades ago, from the right to return,”

Dr Shaath’s forthrightness and honesty is refreshing but clearly indicates that any further negotiations with the Palestinian Authority are a total waste of time.

The Palestinian Authority is apparently hell bent on challenging and confronting President Obama whose National Security Strategy released by the White House in May 2010 declared that the United States would seek two states that will live in peace and security :

“a Jewish state of Israel, with true security, acceptance, and rights for all Israelis and a viable, independent Palestine with contiguous territory that ends the occupation that began in 1967 and realizes the potential of the Palestinian people.”

President Obama had also previously made it clear that sentiments such as those expressed by Dr Shaath are completely unacceptable.

Speaking as a then Senator at a Foreign Policy Forum in Des Moines Iowa  on 18 December 2007 the future President stated: “I think everyone knows what the basic outlines of an agreement would look like. It would mean that the Palestinians would have to reinterpret the notion of right of return in a way that would preserve Israel as a Jewish state. It might involve compensation and other concessions from the Israelis but ultimately Israel is not going to give up its state.”

Secretary of State Hillary Clinton in an address on 29 April 2010 had also made it perfectly clear that: “Since our first day in office, the Obama Administration has made the pursuit of peace and secure and recognized borders for Israel a priority because that is, we believe, the best way to safeguard Israel’s long-term future as a democratic Jewish state.”

Dr Shaath’s statement  also constitutes a rebuff to former President George W Bush who assured Israel’s then Prime Minister Ariel Sharon in a letter dated 14 April 2004:

“The United States is strongly committed to Israel’s security and well-being as a Jewish state”

Dr Shaath has effectively reiterated the long held position of the Palestinian Authority’s surrogate parent – the Palestine Liberation Organization  – whose Charter declares: “Claims of historical or religious ties of Jews with Palestine are incompatible with the facts of history and the true conception of what constitutes statehood. Judaism, being a religion, is not an independent nationality. Nor do Jews constitute a single nation with an identity of its own; they are citizens of the states to which they belong.”

Dr Shaath’s remarks also operate as a clear rejection of a statement made by Israel’s Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu in Israel’s Parliament in July 2010: “The first thing [in negotiations] is Palestinian recognition of the State of Israel as the homeland of the Jewish people. When we are talking about a solution of two states for two peoples, one of these peoples is the Jewish people. It is not some Israeli people, it is the Jewish people.”

With negotiations set to resume between Israel and the Palestinian Authority on 14 September in Sharm El Sheikh  – Prime Minister Netanyahu needs to then make it absolutely clear  that the Palestinian Authority’s stance – as represented by Dr Shaath’s statement – is completely unacceptable to Israel and that Israel will immediately suspend any further negotiations with the Palestinian Authority until it unreservedly disassociates itself from Dr Shaath’s remarks.

Prime Minister Netanyahu was effusive in lauding the Palestinian Authority’s President Mahmoud Abbas as his “partner in peace” in Washington just one week ago.

How this façade can be maintained in the face of a clear statement refusing to acknowledge Israel’s continuing existence as a Jewish State is totally incomprehensible.

It is to be hoped that President Obama will be similarly outspoken and condemn Dr Shaath’s remarks perhaps by repeating the words of concern spoken by him in response to the planned burning of the Koran by Pastor Terry Jones: “It is absolutely important now for the overwhelming majority of American people to hang on to that thing that is best in us – that is our belief in religious tolerance …”

The Palestinian Authority’s position represents a serious threat to the fragile stability in the region. It makes the continuation of any further negotiations meaningless.

Was Dr Shaath’s statement endorsed by the Arab League?  If not – then a strong statement from the Arab League distancing itself from those remarks should also be forthcoming.

The inability of the Arabs to accept a Jewish State in the midst of 21 Islamic Arab states has always been at the heart of resolving the Arab-Jewish conflict.

Dr Shaath’s remarks show that nothing has changed in the Arab psyche that would lead one to hope that Jew-hatred will be replaced by an appreciation that the Jewish state is here to stay.

Suspension of direct negotiations is realistically the only option available to Israel until the Palestinian Authority disavows itself of Dr Shaath’s racist and totally unacceptable remarks.

The Palestinian Authority will have signed its own death warrant if it refuses to do so.

David Singer is a Sydney Lawyer and Foundation Member of the International Analysts Network


4 Responses to “Palestine: Jew Haters – Like Koran Burners – Cannot be Condoned”
  1. Richard ben Serai says:

    This article really bothered me. My wife, adult son and I were in Israel last year and ended up staying – accidently – in a Palestinian hotel in the village on top of HarZayith (Mt. of Olives) in East Jerusalem. As Australians, the locals were friendly to us but those who could speak English always engaged us in conversation which inevitably turned to politics. It was mainly Christian Palestinians whom we dealt with and they expressed a real and genuine fear of the establishment of a recognised Palestinian State and most said that should this happen they would try to immigrate to Israel proper, as refugees. The Palestinine ‘Authority’ is systematically oppressing Palestinian Christians and the demographics show that in traditional Christian areas – Bethlehem etc. – the Christian population is being forced out by intimidation and force, and is now only a shadow of the Christian population of only two or three decades ago.
    Although we didn’t make it specifically known we were Jewish, I guess the kippur, the siddur and my wife’s magan-divid necklace might have given the game away, most Palestinians we encountered were very sympathetic to Judaism and Israel, and hated the ‘hard men’ and the violent politics – they called Hamas and the PLO “gangsters and murdering thugs” but they told us this privately, there was great fear. We should have more news and truthful reporting about how religious minorities in ‘the Palestinian territories’ are being oppressed. I would like to submit a whole article on these matters.

  2. david singer says:

    I agree with M.S.Sharwood’s view that the negotiations are a charade. Can Israel afford to suspend the negotiations until the PA agrees to recognize Israel as the national homeland of the Jewish people? I am of the view that it can and must because after 17 years of negotiations and 62 years of non-recognition it is time to take a stand and end the charade that currently passes for “negotiations”.

  3. M.S.Sharwood says:

    Dr.Nabeel Shaath’s statements merely reinforce the inescapable truth that the Palestinians are merely going through the motions, no doubt to placate Western sensibilities.In the same way, Israel has no choice but to continue the charade, and cannot afford to suspend the negotiations, as suggested, meaningless as they undoubtedly are.

  4. Rita Liddle says:

    Golda Meir said it long ago: “There will only be peace when they love their children more than they hate us”.

    Seeing the virulent and malicious indoctrination by the most vile and jew-demonising “educational TV programmes for Palestinian children”, which by any civilised stardards are serious child abuse, I see no indication of that. 🙁

Speak Your Mind

Comments received without a full name will not be considered
Email addresses are NEVER published! All comments are moderated. J-Wire will publish considered comments by people who provide a real name and email address. Comments that are abusive, rude, defamatory or which contain offensive language will not be published

Got something to say about this?

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.