Islamic State – Confusion, Delusion and Illusion…writes David Singer

July 10, 2015 by David Singer
Read on for article

Australia’s Minister for Communications – Malcolm Turnbull – has sought to play down the threat Islamic State poses to world peace and security with these few throwaway unsubstantiated sentences during an address to the Sydney Institute on 7 July.He said:

“… Da’esh is not Hitler’s Germany, Tojo’s Japan or Stalin’s Russia. Its leaders dream that they, like the Arab armies of the 7th and 8th century, will sweep across the Middle East into Europe itself.

They predict that before long they will be stabling their horses in the Vatican.

We should be careful not to say or do things which can be seen to add credibility to those delusions.”

Turnbull used the term “Daesh” – instead of Islamic State – on 16 occasions during his address.

This was in itself an indication of the confusion that he and other leading politicians around the world are experiencing – continuing to use an outdated Arab acronym from 2013 to identify an enemy whose original objectives have now extended far beyond Syria and Iraq – as its self-declaration of Statehood on 29 June 2014 makes clear:

“Accordingly, the “Iraq and Shām” in the name of the Islamic State is henceforth removed from all official deliberations and communications, and the official name is the Islamic State from the date of this declaration.”

Turnbull ignored that Islamic State has since then seized control of an area of territory in Syria and Iraq larger than Great Britain – whilst 20 groups in Sudan, Philippines, India, Algeria, Afghanistan, Libya, Syria, Egypt, Lebanon, Yemen, Saudi Arabia and most notably Boko Haram in Nigeria have sworn allegiance to Islamic State.


Malcolm Turnbull

Boko Haram has been responsible for tens of thousands of deaths and displacement of an estimated 1 million people in the past year and now reportedly controls an area about 52,000 square kilometres – roughly the size of Slovakia.

Regrettably delusions are the stuff wars are made of – as Hitler’s Germany demonstrated so horribly in World War 11. When fed with declarations of allegiance and support from others their delusional goals become an achievable reality in their warped minds.

Failing to immediately extinguish these Turnbull-identified Islamic State delusions ensures the continuation of the belligerent actions carried out by Islamic State as detailed in Security Council Resolutions 2170 dated 15 August 2014 and 2199 dated 12 February 2015:

  1. the displacement of millions of people,
  2. seizing control of oilfields, dams and power plants,
  3. extortion, kidnap ransoms and stealing money from the territory it controls
  4. abductions of women and children, their exploitation and abuse, including rape, sexual abuse, forced marriage,

Turnbull only mentioned in passing the prescription needed to end such continuing atrocities and the termination of such dangerous delusions:

“The … most important part of the Government’s response to Da’esh, is of course lending the support of our armed forces to defeating them in the field.  The means of doing so are well beyond the scope of this speech, but the roll back and destruction of Da’esh in Iraq and Syria is critical to ending not just their barbaric rule in the Middle East, but their appeal beyond it, even, as we know, to a few of our own citizens.”

The illusion that Islamic State can be destroyed by the 62 nation coalition presently led by America – rather than by a United Nations force sanctioned under Article 42 of Chapter V11 of the United Nations Charter – represents a lack of genuine international will to stop Islamic State – and its threat to international peace and security – dead in its tracks.

The parallels with failing to stop Hitler’s Germany much earlier become clearer with each passing day.

David Singer is an Australian Lawyer, a Foundation Member of the International Analyst Network and Convenor of Jordan is Palestine International.


4 Responses to “Islamic State – Confusion, Delusion and Illusion…writes David Singer”
  1. Rabbi Pinchos Woolstone says:

    Malcolm may have under played the threat and not used the correct and up to date terminologies to describe the terrorist groups, however he is a strong supporter of Israel.
    it may be an idea for those in the leadership of the Jewish Community, who know him well, to dialogue with him on the issues in private.
    He like the PM are friends, we should not allow our well founded concerns for the wellbeing of Israel to create unnecessary alarm.
    I feel confident Malcolm will adjust his public pronouncements on the issues in the future to the satisfaction of the community.

    • david singer says:


      With respect my article dealt with the threat Islamic State poses to world order and security – and will continue to do so – until a Security Council resolution is passed authorising military action by a United Nations force.

      Mr Turnbull’s address had little to do with Israel but a lot to do with the threat faced by the world community from Islamic State and its rapidly growing band of terrorist allegiance-pledgers.

      • Rabbi Pinchos Woolstone says:

        you are correct, the comments made by Malcolm were not Israel specific.
        I sensed however that members of our community may have drawn the inference that Malcolm was not overly concerned as to the threat the terrorists groups like ISIS posed to Israel and the world.
        I apologize for my lack of clarity.

  2. Raymond PHILLIPS says:

    I thought Malcolm Turnbull had more spine than that, resorting to substitute words. If it waddles like a duck, looks like a duck and quacks like a duck guess what its a DUCK you goose. David Cameron the British PM have said not to use the tag IS or Islamic State, a BBC spokesperson has said they will still use IS and / or Islamic State when referring to the terror group, all because they don’t want to harm the silence majority (of muslims) This group is like cancer they are doing it by stealth and on many / most occasions using brute animal force. Politicians need to WAKE UP
    So much for being educated Malcolm

Speak Your Mind

Comments received without a full name will not be considered
Email addresses are NEVER published! All comments are moderated. J-Wire will publish considered comments by people who provide a real name and email address. Comments that are abusive, rude, defamatory or which contain offensive language will not be published

Got something to say about this?

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.