Did you make the Rich List? Ask the rabbi

January 2, 2018 by Rabbi Raymond Apple
Read on for article

Rabbi Raymond Apple answers what makes you rich…

Rabbi Raymond Apple


With the end of a year, many people look back and sum up the events of the past 12 months.

For some the major concern is how much money they made or failed to make, whether interest rates went up or did not go up, whether they got into the “rich list” or missed out once again.

There is no harm in having these conversations with oneself. After all, every month on the Shabbat before Rosh Chodesh we pray for “a life of prosperity and honour”, and we know that Rabbi Yehudah HaNasi, editor of the Mishnah, used to give honour to rich people (Eruvin 86a).

In the light of these facts, I suppose I for one have to conclude that I’m a nobody, a failure. The past year did not make me wealthier. My assets did not appreciably increase. I wasn’t in the rich list last year, and I’m still nowhere in striking distance.

But I am not too disappointed with myself, since it is possible to be rich in other ways. Pirkei Avot asks, “Who is rich?” and the answer is given in psychological, not financial terms. Who is rich? “He who is contented with his lot” (Avot 4:1).

This is not an argument for being a stick-in-the-mud without ambition or drive, a person content to be in a rut. What we are being told is that if you are a stable, settled personality at ease with yourself and without major neuroses, you can regard yourself as fortunate – and rich.

There was once a porter who helped people with their shopping in the Machaneh Yehudah markets in Jerusalem. He went about his work singing “Ana HaShem hoshi’a na” from the “Hallel”. If you asked him why he’s so happy, he replied, “’Baruch HaShem’, I’m rich!” It’s rather obvious that he barely made a living, but he still thinks he’s rich.

If you asked him why, he answered, “’Ani ashir’, I really am rich, because ‘ashir’ is the abbreviation for ‘einayim’, ‘shinayim’, ‘yadayim’, ‘raglayim’ – eyes, teeth, hands and legs. I have a healthy body, and if you have health you have everything. I’m a rich man!”

Isn’t it good to have some money too? Naturally, but it’s not worth it if you’ve gained it less than honestly, if money has become an obsession and if you use your money to bully and bribe your family (“Do as I say or I’ll cut you out of my will!”).

If you have riches, use it wisely. Disraeli said, “Great wealth is a great blessing to him who knows what to do with it”.

Why did Yehudah HaNasi honour rich people? Because if the rich are generous they are useful to the community.

The financial rich list is not for everybody, only for the top 200 or so. But Baruch HaShem, we can all be on the rich list of those who can say Baruch HaShem!


Q. What is a “mamzer”?

A. Much misunderstanding surrounds the law that says, “lo yavo mamzer bik’hal HaShem” – “A mamzer shall not enter the congregation of the Lord” (Deut. 23:3).

The English translations call a mamzer a bastard, which wrongly gives the impression that the mamzer is a child born out of wedlock. In Jewish law, however, the term applies to the child of parents who could never marry each other, either because of adultery (where a married woman has relations with a man other than her husband) or incest.

A child born to parents who were not, but could legally have been, married to each other is not a mamzer.

A second misapprehension applies to the words, “shall not enter the congregation of the Lord”.

The phrase does not imply that the child is not Jewish, that if a male he is not counted towards a minyan, or that he is debarred from holding communal office. A mamzer’s only (though serious) impediment is that he or she may not marry a non-mamzer.

Obviously the child is suffering from the sins of the parents, and the halachah uses every possible leniency in applying the law, but prevention is better than cure, and couples who think of breaking the law should think again.


3 Responses to “Did you make the Rich List? Ask the rabbi”
  1. Lynne Newington says:


    Q. What is a “mamzer”?

    ..”In Jewish law, however, the term applies to the child of parents who could never marry each other…..

    I wonder what religious/bibical law the following would apply too.

    Errant priests’ secret children to sue church….

    When Pat Bond told her lover Henry Willenborg, a Franciscan priest, that she was pregnant, he urged her to have an abortion.

    Bond, who was 28, had a miscarriage and then became pregnant again. This time Willenborg’s superiors urged her to give up the child for adoption.

    Bond, from Missouri, kept the child but agreed to a vow of silence. In a signed contract with the Catholic Church, she undertook to keep the priest’s identity secret in exchange for financial support for her son, Nathan.

    In America, Britain, Ireland, Germany, France, Italy and Austria,women made pregnant by priests have signed such pledges in exchange for hush money from the church.
    That includes Australia not previously mentioned.


  2. Lynne Newington says:

    One needs to be careful for what they wish for…..another Jewish rabbi once declared it is easier for a camel to go through
    the eye of a needle than for a rich man to enter the kingdom of God.”
    I’m safe!

Speak Your Mind

Comments received without a full name will not be considered
Email addresses are NEVER published! All comments are moderated. J-Wire will publish considered comments by people who provide a real name and email address. Comments that are abusive, rude, defamatory or which contain offensive language will not be published

Got something to say about this?

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.