Waks answers his criticss

June 29, 2011 by J-Wire Staff
Read on for article

The Capital Jewish Forum and its founder Manny Waks have been criticised following the announcement of functions it will hold in Melbourne.

Waks answers his critics:

from Manny Waks

Manny Waks

After much consideration, I have decided to respond to some of the reaction to the Capital Jewish Forum’s (CJF) inaugural Melbourne event featuring the Palestinian Authority Head of Delegation, Mr Izzat Abdulhadi.

Although criticism that has been raised is largely associated with the Executive Council of Australian Jewry (ECAJ), it is clearly not universally supported within its membership.

The issues are apparently directed at “turf”, an alleged “conflict of interest”, and the efficacy of a “platform” that is provided to the de facto Palestinian Ambassador.

Turf: I have been told, unequivocally, that Victoria is the “turf” of the Victorian roof bodies. Indeed, a leader of a prominent Victorian organisation informed me that Victoria is “my turf”. Reluctantly, I must say that this is at best a parochial, and at worst an immature issue to be raised by representative bodies.

There should be no territorial claims within the Jewish community, nor justification for claim to territorial sovereignty. Of course local issues are best dealt with by local representatives, but that is not relevant in this case.  In fact the CJF is effectively a national group; currently with over 550 national email subscribers. The CJF is not in “competition” with other groups. Holding an event in Melbourne is a natural progression for the CJF from its Canberra-based activities and this vision has been articulated publicly in various forums, including directly to some within the Jewish community leadership group. It should be noted that the CJF has a national (and international) Board of Advisors. The provision of events beyond Canberra has been largely driven by the subscribers in other States.

Conflict of interest: Subsequent to the announcement of the inaugural CJF Melbourne event with the Palestinian representative, the ECAJ has stated that my roles as Vice President of ECAJ and Executive Director of CJF are in conflict. This is disingenuous. I have held these dual roles since September 2010, and during that time coordinated numerous CJF events in Canberra. During this period the ECAJ has never suggested any conflict of interest. On the contrary, there have been supportive affirmations for the CJF. Further, many in the Jewish leadership group have dual roles in a plethora of organisations.

Palestinian representative: The CJF has previously hosted Mr Abdulhadi in Canberra, in November 2009, which elicited no criticism whatsoever. As an important part of its mission, the CJF offers a platform for a vigorous exchange of differing views; it is certainly not intended to endorse the views of speakers, nor is it perceived as such by any participant. For example, the CJF has hosted in Canberra ambassadors from Israel, the US, France, Jordan, Pakistan, Turkey, Hungary and the EU, among others. It has also hosted senior Federal politicians on both sides, as well as senior public servants. In July the CJF will again be hosting the US Ambassador, this time in Melbourne.

Other groups operate according to a similar model. For instance, the American Jewish Committee (AJC), a staunchly pro-Israel US group, regularly engages representatives of countries whose State policy is anti-Israel. For instance, the AJC recently met with the Foreign minister of Bahrain and had planned a meeting with a senior Lebanese delegation.

In undertaking this event, the CJF adheres to its mission to promote “discussion and engagement with intellectuals, dignitaries and leaders on topics which are relevant to Jewish academic, policy, business and other professionals.” The CJF is non-partisan and offers a unique, alternative communal model based on personal empowerment, aiming to enrich the existing communal structures. Through regular events, the CJF not only exposes Jewish academic, policy, business and other professionals to a diversity of views within the Jewish community, but also provides direct engagement and interaction with intellectuals, dignitaries and leaders on topics of importance to the Jewish community. The culture of inclusiveness that defines the CJF model is also particularly attractive to Jewish professionals who may be otherwise disengaged from and/or unaffiliated with existing communal institutions.

The CJF provides an opportunity for our community to ask the “tough questions” of the Distinguished Guests who represent their respective countries or organisations. Moreover, this form of direct engagement is consistent with the developing model within the global Jewish community, particularly desired by and attractive to the younger age demographic.

It is important to emphasise that the CJF does not claim to represent anyone within the Jewish community – it merely acts as a facilitator. This matter is brought to the attention of all Distinguished Guests, whom I also make aware of my own pro-Israel views where appropriate.

I have been pleased to receive explicit support from the ACT Jewish Community Board of Management, and appreciate their unanimous motion conveying their support in response to the recent criticism.

I look forward to seeing many in the Melbourne Jewish community at the CJF event with Mr Abdulhadi, as well as at the event with the US Ambassador, His Excellency Jeffrey Bleich. Hopefully the CJF will facilitate many additional future events throughout Australia.

For more information on the CJF or to RSVP to the event, please see www.capitaljewishforum.org or email capitaljewishforum@gmail.com.


Manny Waks is President of the ACT Jewish Community, Vice President of the Executive Council of Australian Jewry and Executive Director of the Capital Jewish Forum.




9 Responses to “Waks answers his criticss”
  1. Otto Waldmann says:

    CJF is doing a great job, indeed, demonstrating that, in a free and almost unaccountable society, one’s quest for prominence could be boundless.For what could, indeed, stop CJF’s leader from rearranging the political agenda of a community, indeed a cause, which has established with firmness that ALL palestinian officials carry a degree of deceit within which the MOST reliable element is their unabated desire to destroy Israel – has vsholem !
    A facade of acquired politness, painted smiles and even moderate speeches have been demonstrated to be used quite efficiently by the palestinian, totally anti Israel camp, as useful wheapons in demonstrating that the said anti Israel camp has matured into a “civilised”, “reasonable” and all such positive features, while the inflexible Israel continues its own complete opposite type of policies to a reformed and acceptable palestinian entity.
    Classically, we are fighting the enemies we create and multi-president Wax, by design and feverish desire, seems to know best how to approach all above issues . But, hey, look I am getting PERSONAL and that’s a definite NO NO, even when one answers a …person engaged in a very individualised communal strategy. Yes, we are allowed to praise a person, but, G-d forbid critcise the same……

  2. Juan says:

    Manny, keep up the good job you’re doing!! I can’t understand very well the reasons behind the opposition to the CJF hosting this event…

    Juan .

  3. Sandy says:

    I have no objection to CJF hosting the PA rep in Australia to a forum. However I hope that the organizers and friends of Israel and the Jewish people who attend will remember that he represents an enemy of the Jewish people. The “Palestinian narrative” and in fact “Palestinian nationality” are concocted fictions with the primary objective of delegitimizing and destroying Israel. The fact that Abbas recently swore that the Palestinian state he aims to create will “not have a single Jew in it” should make it clear that peaceful coexistence is not on his agenda. ( … and he’s the “moderate” amongst them).
    So, for the benefit of the ill-informed in the audience, I trust that CJF will ensure that informed alternative views to that of their speaker will also be heard at the event.

  4. I aplaude Manny Waks’ response and totally agree and sympathise with his difficult and ambitious role in hosting seminars that raise contentious issues which drive some people’s emotions to react unreasonably. Bring on the debate, there is no point in preaching to the converted !

  5. Manny Waks says:

    Thank you all for your kind and supportive words. I look forward to continuing with this initiative.

  6. Brian Wimborne says:

    Dear Manny,

    Parochialism and small mindedness should not deter you. Keep up the good work.

  7. Yael says:

    Manny, I suspect the old “green-eyed monster” of envy is rearing its head. You are doing a great job.

  8. simon bedak says:

    As a Sydney based member of the CJF, I have had the pleasure of attending several functions in Canberra when I was there during the past year. No other regular forum I can think of produces the scope of access to embassies, good food and fine company that the CJF facilitates and encourages. If Mr Waks ever decided to bring the feast up to Sydney, I’d look forward to welcoming him in my home town with as much hospitality as he has so very kindly shown to my family when I’ve been in Canberra.


    Simon Bedak

  9. gary says:

    Manny, you are doing a great job, and I look forward to attending the Melbourne event.

    No wonder there are so few young adults taking on leadership positions like you.
    Getting attacked by the elders of the community is probably not pleasant, and not an inspiring introduction to communal politics.

    I hope CJF opens in all states. The powers that be feel threatened by a young dynamic organisation. Turf wars are so 1980s.

Speak Your Mind

Comments received without a full name will not be considered
Email addresses are NEVER published! All comments are moderated. J-Wire will publish considered comments by people who provide a real name and email address. Comments that are abusive, rude, defamatory or which contain offensive language will not be published

Got something to say about this?

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.