Palestine – Rudd, Carr And Labor Sink In Silence…writes David Singer

September 1, 2013 by David Singer
Read on for article

Australia’s Prime Minister – Kevin Rudd and Foreign Minister – Senator Bob Carr – remain hell bent on consigning the Labor Party to Opposition and the political wilderness in this week’s elections.

This view has been confirmed by Dan Goldberg in an article in Haaretz on 27 August titled “Jewish support swinging towards Liberal Party in Australian election”

” The latest polls predict the Liberal Party will win the September 7 election by 53 percent to Labor’s 47 percent. Voting is mandatory and Orthodox Jews have started to pre-poll because all Australian elections are held on Saturdays.

If the polls are accurate, it would spell the end of a bitter  battle between Foreign Minister Bob Carr and Jewish leaders, who were infuriated in January when he joined British Foreign Secretary William Hague in stating that all Israeli settlements are “illegal under international law.”

Carr, a founder of the New South Wales Parliamentary Friends of Israel group in the 1970s, reignited Jewish angst last month in a speech outside Australia’s largest mosque. “All settlements on Palestinian land are illegal under international law and should cease,” he said. “That is the position of Kevin Rudd, the position of the federal Labor government, and we don’t make apologies for it.”

When the inevitable post mortems are written after the elections – Carr’s Lakemba Mosque Declaration tying Rudd and the Labor Party to Carr’s own previously expressed viewpoint will be seen as emblematic of the failure of Rudd and the Labor Party to be honest and upfront with the Australian voters on a range of issues during the elections.

The Lakemba Mosque Declaration came as a complete surprise to the Executive Council  of Australian Jewry, the Australia Israel Jewish Affairs Council and the Zionist Federation of Australia – who were quick to voice their disapproval of what was in effect anti-Jewish-policy made on the run on the steps of the Mosque – not by the Prime Minister – but by his Foreign Minister.

Attempts to have Rudd confirm or deny that the views attributed to him and the Labor Party by Carr were in fact their views – have been studiously ignored and still remain unanswered by Rudd.

Instead Carr’s spokesman weighed in with the following mealy-mouthed statement:

“Words are very important and it’s important they are not misrepresented. Yes, we have expressed “concern”, we have expressed “grave concern” and we have expressed “disappointment” in relation to the settlements.This does not amount to a condemnation of Israel or anything like it.”

Who the “we” is and when those words were used was left up in the air.

What was clearly said at the Mosque were the words “illegal in international law”, “cease”, ” the position of Kevin Rudd “, the position of the Labor Federal Government” ” and “we don’t make apologies”

Labor Federal MP for Melbourne Ports Michael Danby however was more forthright when telling JWire about Carr’s comments on Israeli settlements:

“Bob Carr’s emphasis on Israeli settlements is ill timed, given the peace negotiations that are currently taking place in Washington. These talks commenced, and are supported by Australia, on the basis that they are undertaken without preconditions.

One of the issues, and it is only one, of the issues being negotiated in Washington is settlements and land swaps. Obviously therefore Australia should not pre-empt negotiations freely entered into by the parties involved.”

Rudd and Carr have failed to respond to allegations that the Lakemba Mosque Declaration was made to attract Moslem voters back to the Labor Party after another disastrous piece of policy on the run – denying future Moslem asylum seekers coming to Australia by boat any right to resettlement in Australia.

Moslem votes are considered to be crucial to Labor retaining a number of narrowly held marginal seats – especially in western Sydney and in Victoria – but the Herald Sun reported on 23 August – confirmed again this week:

“LABOR is facing a wipeout in must-win seats along the eastern seaboard as the federal election campaign enters its final fortnight.

An exclusive Galaxy Poll for the Herald Sun reveals the marginal Victorian seats of Corangamite and La Trobe are set to fall to the Coalition on September 7.

Five critical Labor-held seats in western Sydney are also likely to tumble, including heartland seats such as Gough Whitlam’s former electorate of Werriwa.”

Rudd’s continuing refusal to confirm in a one sentence press release that the Lakemba Mosque declaration is Labor Party policy has apparently convinced Moslem voters that Carr’s declaration was only hot air and political grandstanding.

Trying to play the ethnic card has only had the effect of upsetting both Jewish and Moslem voters – as well as other ethnic groups – during this election campaign.

Now facing possible defeat in his own electorate – a desperate Rudd could still be considering breaking his silence to assure Moslem voters that it is his view – and indeed Labor party policy – that Jews have no right to live in the West Bank.

It will be too little and too late – and would anyone now believe him – after refusing for three weeks to clear up the confusion created by his own Foreign Minister.

Trusting your politicians to say what they mean and mean what they say still ranks very highly in securing many peoples’ votes on Election Day.

Rudd and Carr’s sordid saga of deception and confusion in this and many other issues has only succeeded in turning voters away in droves.

David Singer is a Sydney Lawyer and Foundation Member of the International Analysts Network


8 Responses to “Palestine – Rudd, Carr And Labor Sink In Silence…writes David Singer”
  1. Ben David says:


    If Julie Bishop become our next Foreign Minister over the weekend, will you request and then publish her statement declaring all the settlements legal under international law ?


  2. Otto Waldmann says:

    Don’t correct me if any of you thinks that I am wrong. I am NOT wrong !! And I will even tell you what about :

    I love an argument and it seems almost anything with a legal whiff about it must take the shape of an argument.
    To be fair, in the entire legal literature regarding Israel there is no better mid than David Singer’s. I won’t go into details because we can all witness his diligence ( se I am using dedicated forensic lingo, “diligence”, “witness” and further down I intend to use even “objection”.
    So, as if completely oblivious to all these legal impressive efforts, what does the Israel Govt. do ? They go on their merry ways and build wherever they know that the land belongs to the Jewish State. If anyone would like to argue on the ground about the tangible evidence, Israel would not have any objection (!!!!). They would let them have a chat with the Caterpillar workers on the building sites, or the brickies, tradies of all description. One warning though, if you want an argument on the ground you better be good at Arabic, simply because most of the workers there are…………..

  3. Gedalia says:

    Exceptional analysis. Bring on the day of judgement! What could be better than a three day yomtov culminating in the punishment of whose who have delivered us poor Government.

  4. sharwood says:

    International law is firmly on the side of the view that the West Bank can be closely settled by Jews.There is no sovereignty over the land, yet. The Jewish claim is far stronger than any other claim. Yet the International community insists on saying that the area is ‘occupied.’ That assumes that the land belonged to the Palestinians. But it never did. It was part of The Jewish National home, later enshrined in International law, as such. In 1948 it was conquered by Jordan, and in 1967, re-taken by Israel. Israel took back land upon which Jews were permitted to settle. The Geneva Convention arguments simply do not apply,because the land was Jewish to start with.It’s time Mr.Carr and the rest of the International community were properly advised.

    • Gil Solomon says:


      Properly advised by whom?

      The main person to advise the international community on all of this is a well spoken knowledgeable representative of Israel.

      Unfortunately, Israel has abandoned Hasbara to its detriment and only the deceitful and false Palestinian narrative has been getting out for decades.

      It’s time Israel woke up and if they have no one to speak effectively they should hire someone from the diaspora, make that person an honorary Israeli citizen to get out there to change the perspective and set the record straight.

      We all have to face it. Israeli Hasbara efforts to date have been just appalling.

  5. steve says:

    Let these antisemites drown in their own words as they sit oon the opposition benches eternally

  6. Otto Waldmann says:

    “….not with a bang, but with a whimper”. Vale Labor lust for power at any cost, deceit and betrayal of those who trusted you in earnest. Lest the call of the muezzin decry de demise of those ho deserve to be lost in the wilderness of disdain and shame, for this Rosh Hashana we shall celebrate to worthy misery in the defeat of the unworthy.

    I said somewhere here, but it needs repeating. Michael Danby put on display his unsuccessful attempt to save the face of those who for years treated him with the attention the polite gives the loyal doorman. Laughable last song of undeserved praise. No , Michael, the “timing” was not ill, the whole concept is chronically ill, but how could you see it, confined, as you are to Party docility. That stupid statement has NO good time to be seen or heard at all, except if one panders to those for whom the smell of Jewish blood is more passionately important than the love for their own children. Your Party can keep them !! No doubt useful stormtroopers if you can still dream to assault the Australian political scene.
    Just a thought, ALP can only increase its constituent membership base if it will join the International Islamic Tribal Union or whatever similar.

  7. Gil Solomon says:


    It seems that the reality of what I wrote in response to your previous post has finally sunk in.

    Labor and all other leftist parties are inherently anti-Israel.

    No matter that individuals within the party may not be so and no matter that Jews may be members. These people will never sway the majority anti-Israel opinion within the party.

Speak Your Mind

Comments received without a full name will not be considered
Email addresses are NEVER published! All comments are moderated. J-Wire will publish considered comments by people who provide a real name and email address. Comments that are abusive, rude, defamatory or which contain offensive language will not be published

Leave a Reply to Gil Solomon Cancel reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.