NY Times amends Barghouti op-ed amid outcry, prisoner hunger strike continues

April 19, 2017 by Adam Abrams - JNS.org
Read on for article

A day after convicted Palestinian terrorist Marwan Barghouti wrote a New York Times op-ed that omitted his crimes and terrorist organisation membership and sparked scathing rebuke from the international community, the newspaper added a brief editor’s note acknowledging the murder and terror-related convictions that led to his imprisonment.

Marwan Barghouti in Israeli court Aug. 14, 2002. Credit: Flash90.

The April 16 piece – where the Times referred to Barghouti as a “Palestinian leader and parliamentarian” – was slammed by Israeli officials and Jewish leaders in the U.S. and elsewhere.

Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said Tuesday, “I read, on Sunday, the article in The New York Times that presents arch-terrorist Marwan Barghouti as a ‘parliamentarian and leader.’ The paper recanted after we pointed it out to them.”

“Calling Barghouti a ‘political leader’ is like calling Assad a ‘pediatrician,’ Netanyahu added. “They are murderers and terrorists.”

Barghouti, who used the Times as a platform to accuse Israel of conducting “mass arbitrary arrests and ill-treatment of Palestinian prisoners,” was convicted in June 2004 for killing five people – including the death of a Christian Greek Orthodox priest that he mistook for a Jewish rabbi – and the attempted murder of another. He is currently serving five life sentences and 40 additional years for the murders.

The editor’s note clarifies, “This article explained the writer’s prison sentence but neglected to provide sufficient context by stating the offense of which he was convicted. They were five counts of murder and membership in a terrorist organisation.”

The Times’s public editor, Liz Spayd, criticise the paper’s op-ed department for its failure to list the crimes committed by Barghouti, writing that “failing to do so risks the credibility of the author and the Op-Ed pages.”

The op-ed was also criticised across the political spectrum in Israel.

Yesh Atid chairman MK Yair Lapid criticised the article stating Barghouti “was involved in dozens of terror attacks that made people lose family, that maimed innocents, that ruined people’s lives. The New York Times ‘forgot’ to tell its readers that.”

Bayit Yehudi chairman Naftali Bennett weighed in via Facebook, posting a picture of one of the terrorist’s victims and writing, “Marwan Barghouti is a heinous murderer who should rot in jail until the day he dies.”

Meanwhile, Barghouti, initiated a hunger strike Sunday, following weeks of preparation, that now involves over 1,100 Palestinian prisoners in the Gilboa, Meggido, Nafha, Ketziot, Shikma, Ramon, Hadarim and Nitzan prisons.

The prisoners are demanding improved conditions such as the installation of pay phones in all prison wings, as well as allowing more frequent family visits.

A spokesperson for the Israel Prison Service told JNS.org, “Hunger strikes in prison endanger the health and life of the prisoners in custody of the state who’s in charge of their well-being and are violations of the discipline and order. Organized hunger strikes even more so.”

Prison officials have started “disciplinary measures towards the striking prisoners and transferring them into separate cell blocks,” the spokesman said. These strikes are not new to Israeli prisons and officials do not negotiate with prisoners. Security officials are prepared for the possibility of a strike and coordinate with other organisations such as the IDF, the Ministry of Health and police.

In response to the hunger strike, Barghouti has been moved to solitary confinement. Officials are investigating whether Barghouti’s op-ed was transmitted to the newspaper through his attorney or if Barghouti’s wife penned the article.

While Barghouti is affiliated with Fatah, the largest faction of the PLO headed by Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas, his hunger strike caused other Palestinian factions to unite behind his effort.

Issa Qaraqe, head of the Palestinian Prisoners Society, said in a statement, “the Palestinian people, in every place where it lives, declared today that the prisoners’ issue is sacred to it and that the occupation government will not enjoy quiet and security as long as it violates the rights of the Palestinian people and harms its prisoners.”

“The Palestinian people declared today an intifada on behalf of the prisoners who are conducting a campaign whose foundation is a hunger strike for their rights and their dignity,” the statement said.

At the same time, Barghouti’s actions may also undermine and threaten Abbas. Despite being imprisoned for over a decade, Barghouti remains a popular figure among Palestinians and is rumored to be a successor to Abbas. As such, Abbas sought to capitalize on the latest efforts, releasing a statement in support of the hunger strike and called on the international community to intervene.

Abu Obeida, a spokesman for the Gaza-based Palestinian terror group, Hamas, said Monday that the release of the Palestinian prisoners is a top priority for the organisation.

Protests in support of the hunger strike were held in several Palestinian areas throughout Judea and Samaria, most prominently in Ramallah, which saw over 2,000 protestors march through the streets waving Palestinian flags and holding pictures of Marwan Barghouti.

In response, Israeli Knesset member Osama Saadia (Joint List) said, “We are certain that all of the Palestinian prisoners are united in this campaign, which is a campaign for the liberty of the Palestinian people.”

Another Joint List Knesset member, Aida Touma-Suliman, applied for a permit to visit Barghouti in prison.



3 Responses to “NY Times amends Barghouti op-ed amid outcry, prisoner hunger strike continues”
  1. Adrian Jackson says:

    The people who blew up the King David Hotel, killing dozens including Jewish hotel staff, were never gaoled nor the ones that murders a UN envoy (a Scandinavian nobleman)and his driver just before partition in 1948.

  2. LIZZIE MOORE says:

    “….and sparked scathing rebuke from the international community, the newspaper added a brief editor’s note, acknowledging the murder and terror-related convictions that led to his imprisonment.”

    Mmm, does seem to imply, that but for the big dust kick up, the kindly editor would have left the piece just as it was! Todah for this article; missed it in the Israeli media.

  3. LIZZIE MOORE says:

    Bit of an eye-opener but then again one reads often, that the New York Times is the Empress of Liberalism in the US and that it drags all the other quality dailies in its wake, eg. Washington Post, Boston Globe, Phillie Inquirer, LA Times, Chicago Tribune, and the rest. With the same applying to anti-Israelism, eg. the relentless hyper-criticism of The Land, which is the now established Western Leftie mode. [Lizzie via Bendigo]

Speak Your Mind

Comments received without a full name will not be considered
Email addresses are NEVER published! All comments are moderated. J-Wire will publish considered comments by people who provide a real name and email address. Comments that are abusive, rude, defamatory or which contain offensive language will not be published

Leave a Reply to LIZZIE MOORE Cancel reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.