Trotsky highlights the most important of these ‘zigzags’ in the field of economic policy, criticizing Stalin and Bukharin’s policy of at first opposing voluntary collectivization and increasing privatization of land and then of an abrupt U-turn to break-neck industrialisation and forced collectivisation, which Trotsky brands “economic adventurism” that carried “the nation to the edge of disaster ”

Extract from a biography of Trotsky,which shows that he was against collectivisation

Poor Adrian has once again exposed himself as ignorant and the master of spin.Trotsky was persona non grata in Russia so his views were never adopted by the powers that be.In fact he was assinated on the orders of Stalin,who was the founder of collectivisation in the USSR.

Collective farms were started by Joseph Stalin in about 1929.The first Kibbutz was started in 1909.
Adrian you have got your history mixed up.

Looks like Adrian has left the building.

Intolerance of an organisation that promotes bigotry,hatred and prejudice.

Adrian sounds like a callow youth.I doubt he knows the meaning of the word.He should call J.Gillard for an explanation.

Just read that Ringo Starr is having two concerts in Israel fairly soon.
I wonder if the B.D.S. stooges will be writing to him. I can imagine his reply!!

Thanks for your comment and support Rafi.I made a decision some time ago not to engage ignorant, armchair slogan posters.
Sadly, Adrian seems to fit this description. I’d love him to be able to back up his ” misogynist ” accusation but he won’t because he can’t.
Shalom.

Nothing Stan has written is any way a display of misogyny and you are a guilty of uneducated pomposity.
Adrian you sound like an undergraduate finding their way through a world of complexity,holding onto cliches without any form of understanding nor wisdom.

Yes really. Demonising Israel is a good career move at many universities today.

Institutions such as SOAS ( a college of The University of London ) are so anti Israel and anti Semitic that it has been RENAMED – The School of Anti Semitism.
Religious Jews are vilified and abused particularly when wearing kipot at this institution where anti Zionism is seen as a politically correct expression of anti Semitism.