Jews in the Lucky Country – Isi Leibler visits Australia

September 25, 2010 by J-Wire
Read on for article

I returned with my wife Naomi on the eve of Rosh Hashana from a brief visit to Australia, frequently referred to as Down Under, being the most geographically distant destination from Europe (and Israel).

Isi Leibler

Besides visiting family and friends, the principal purpose of our visit was to partake in a major fund-raising event in Melbourne, hosted by Australian Emunah, a constituent of the global religious Zionist women’s organization which Naomi currently heads as world president. Emunah last year was the recipient of the Israel Prize in recognition of its extensive network of children’s homes and welfare institutions catering for all disadvantaged Israelis.

The keynote speaker was former Australian prime minister John Howard and during the evening, we both made reference to his visit to Israel on the eve of the second intifada when he had persuaded me reluctantly to join him when he met Yasser Arafat in Gaza. After the meeting, I expressed reservations about Arafat, suggesting that a duplicitous murderer was unlikely to change his spots. Howard vowed that if Arafat failed to adhere to his commitments “the people of Israel and the Australian Jewish community should rest assured that I will not let them down.”

He certainly fulfilled that promise, emerging during the 11 years of his term as one of Israel’s staunchest international friends.

During my visit, Australia was undergoing a political crisis. Julia Gillard, who had displaced her Labor prime minister Kevin Rudd a few months earlier, had called for an election. Many traditional Labor voters, angered by the brutal displacement of her predecessor, voted against their party, resulting in a hung Parliament which was only resolved when four independent parliamentarians ultimately endorsed her.

PRIOR TO World War II, Australian Jewry was a decaying Anglo Jewish outpost. It was the flow of refugees and Holocaust survivors which enriched and transformed the community into what is today considered one of the most thriving and dynamic Jewish diasporas. Many who found haven in Australia succeeded and prospered. Today, strengthened by recent infusions from Russia and South Africa, there are approximately 120,000 Jews principally concentrated in three cities – Melbourne, Sydney and Perth.

Australian Jewry is frequently depicted as a role model for other Diaspora communities. Having, aside from Israel, the highest proportion of Holocaust survivors, it is dominated by painful memories but is also a forwardlooking Zionist community.

The community created an extraordinary network of day schools and cultural institutions catering to all Jewish religious and cultural streams. The majority of graduates partake in courses in Israel ranging from three months to a year and more than 12, 000 Australians have made aliya. Intermarriage while growing is much lower than in other Western Jewish communities.

Until the 1950s, Australia was a far cry from the country of today. It was racist, bigoted ,anti-Semitic and notorious for its White Australia policy. However by absorbing migrants from all corners of the world, Australia evolved into a unique multicultural society, open-minded, liberal and tolerant. Yet, today, determined not to follow the disastrous example of Europe which provided free rein to minorities opposing the central tenets of democracy and freedom, many Australians realize that multiculturalism can only succeed if the participants share a commitment to the open society. Today, despite growing anti-Semitism, the standing of the Jews is similar to the US and the influence of Muslim migrants is limited.

Australian Jews are proud that since the birth of Israel, with only one exception, consecutive Australian governments have remained strongly supportive. The links go back to Australian soldiers who served in Palestine in both world wars and developed warm relations with Jews in the Yishuv in 1940-41.

Australia has also been highly supportive of major Jewish global endeavors such as the struggle to free Soviet Jewry. As far back as 1962, it became the first country to raise the issue of Soviet anti-Semitism and the refusal to grant Jews the right to make aliya at the UN. Former refuseniks will recall that the Australian embassy in Moscow was highly forthcoming in extending whatever help and support possible and even held receptions for them. In my visits to the Soviet Union, successive Australian prime ministers, despite incurring the rage of the Soviet authorities, instructed the Moscow embassy to provide me with transportation and support in meeting refuseniks.

The government also played a major role in the struggle to rescind the UN resolution bracketing Zionism with racism and assisted Australian Jewish leaders in their efforts to help pave the way for diplomatic relations between Israel and both India and China.

MUCH OF the credit for this can be attributed to a united Jewish leadership which was never reticent in raising its voice to confront governments displaying bias against the Jewish state or conforming to the anti-Israeli stance of the international community. There was also a longstanding tradition by the Jewish community to facilitate visits to Israel for a wide cross-section of parliamentarians. Likewise, the Australia-Israel Chamber of Commerce emerged as possibly the most effective and successful of all the chambers of commerce.

The Australia-Israel relationship was strengthened during the 11 years of the Howard government. Over the past year, just prior to the overthrow of prime minister Rudd by his own party, there were concerns that the policy had tilted against Israel because the government was canvassing support for election to the UN Security Council. Following a meeting with the national Jewish leadership, the situation appeared to have been resolved but was never tested because shortly afterward, Gillard displaced Rudd.

It would seem that today bipartisan support for Israel will be maintained. However, there are concerns. Gillard is regarded as being evenhanded and friendly, but the Labor Party was obliged to forge an alliance with the Greens whose attitude toward Israel is highly antagonistic. However, most of her new cabinet is pro-Israel, as is the powerful opposition.

Of course, all is not rosy. The younger generation, like its global counterparts, lacks the passion of its forbears who lived during the Holocaust and witnessed the struggle to establish the State of Israel. The cost of day school education has risen considerably, with many parents unwilling to match the sacrifices of their parents to ensure a Jewish education for their children. The level of intermarriage, while low compared to the US and most European countries, is growing.

There is also a discernible change in the political climate. Australian trade unions, traditionally bastions of support for Israel, now even endorse anti-Israeli boycotts. The churches, many of which were previously hostile, have intensified their anti-Israeli approach. Anti-Israeli activity at universities is escalating and encouraged by a number of Jewish academics. Anti-Zionist Jewish splinter groups have emerged although in contrast to the US, they are totally marginalized from the mainstream.

Yet notwithstanding these emerging challenges, if there were more Jewish communities like Australia, the future of Diaspora Jewry would be far more secure than it is.

Comments

8 Responses to “Jews in the Lucky Country – Isi Leibler visits Australia”
  1. samuel says:

    I notice Isi praises multiculturalism in Australia but does not feel the same way about for Israel.

  2. Shirlee. says:

    Grant I suggest you do some searching for these facts. I was as astounded as you a few years on being confronted with this information

    Start with THE JEWISH REFUGEES IN AUSTRALIA BY DR. D. BERGER

    I have plenty of information on this, unfortunately this web site doesn’t allow for attachments, and they are all on PDF format

    • Grant says:

      Who? Isi’s ideas opinions? You think they are the truth? His ideas are for lemmings and more left wing rubbish with some lies. I refuted them below I cant see anything by Dr Berger that supports the nonsense Isi wrote.

      • Shirlee says:

        It’s well documented as were the cartoons the day

        Borrow this book from the National Library

        http://trove.nla.gov.au/work/17413602?selectedversion=NBD24295833

        Read page 129 by Prof Suzanne Rutland

        • Grant says:

          I can’t get to page 129 but whatever it is your still clinging to the multicultural dream like the lemmings in Europe who are now finding that they can’t be Jews in Europe anymore as its become so enriched. I have my own oral histories about being Jewish in Australia passed down to me that are in direct CONTRADICTION to the baseless generalisations made by Isi.

          • Shirlee says:

            Grant,

            You have to join the library to borrow it. You can’t just read it.

            J-Wire has your email address. I can ask them to send the PDF I have to you

            You have a computer, what’s your issue with searching as I have just done?

            http://www.ijs.org.au/Jewish-Immigration-after-the-Second-World-War/default.aspx

            “”If the administration was against allowing in Jews, its guilt was eased by the great number of Australian Jews,
            who were scared of a flood of European Jews. The Jewish Welfare Society was proud that it had had the full trust
            of the leadership which in fact banned the immigration of Jewish refugees.”””

  3. Grant says:

    I don’t know where he gets this statement that Australia was a racist anti semitic place in the 1950s. Thats the exact opposite of what it was. Antisemitism never meant much in Australia. We had governors and our general in WW1 as leaders from the Jewish religion. The white Australia policy is a 19th century construct that was implemented to maintain working class wages and conditions. yes it was racist as the other races would have worked for less! He then rambles on about the wonders of multiculturalism. Well multiculturalism saw Australia recently abandon Israel at the UN thanks to the ALP and its ridiculous fright that muslims from western sydney ( brought in under multiculturalism thanks to the likes of Isi) won’t vote the socialist ALP anymore. Kind of makes his statement that muslim immigrant influence is limited the kind of dreamy whimisical nonsense the rest of his generalisations of Australia are. Nice own goal with multiculturalism there Isi, for you and the rest of us.

  4. Grant says:

    I don’t know where he gets this statement that Australia was a racist anti semitic place in the 1950s. Thats the exact opposite of what it was. Antisemitism never meant much in Australia. We had governors and our general in WW1 as leaders from the Jewish religion. The white Australia policy is a 19th century construct that was implemented to maintain working class wages and conditions. yes it was racist as the other races would have worked for less! He then rambles on about the wonders of multiculturalism. Well multiculturalism saw Australia recently abandon Israel at the UN thanks to the ALP and its ridiculous fright that muslims from western sydney ( brought in under multiculturalism thanks to the likes of Isi) won’t vote the socialist ALP anymore. Kind of makes his statement that muslim immigrant influence is limited the kind of dreamy whimisical nonsense the rest of his generalisations of Australia are. Nice own goal with multiculturalism there Isi, for you and the rest of us.

Speak Your Mind

Comments received without a full name will not be considered
Email addresses are NEVER published! All comments are moderated. J-Wire will publish considered comments by people who provide a real name and email address. Comments that are abusive, rude, defamatory or which contain offensive language will not be published

    Rules on posting comments